Piper and Jackson are 7-year-old twins. Piper has a loose tooth and everyone has an opinion about how it should come out. Piper likes her tooth and wants to keep it. Then the tooth falls down the drain and Piper's dad can't get it out and she's afraid the Tooth Fairy won't bring her a gift. Piper decides to get Dad's tools and tries to get the tooth out of the drain herself. She then floods the bathroom. Her family comes together to help clean up the floor and later the Tooth Fairy leaves her a mirror as a surprise.